≡ Menu

IP Answer Man: Why Education and Persuasion Won’t Kill IP, but Technology Might: Locke’s Mistake, and Why We’re Stuck with IP Until It’s Unenforceable

The query below, about someone being “called a communist by my boss for expressing my opinion against there being IP at all” reminds me of an encounter I had yesterday. I was leaving Southland Hardware store. My car was parked outside, with my MISES license plate with the Don’t Tread On Me motto and rattlesnake. Two guys were talking outside. One said “Is that your car?” I said yeah. He said “I took a picture of your license plate, hope you don’t mind… say, are you who I think you are?” I said “Probably.” So then he tells me he has read my work and knows an IP lawyer and showed him my anti-IP arguments and the IP lawyer went ballistic and basically said I was the devil. Haha. Good to know.

BTW this is another example of the various ways people find out about new ideas: libertarianism, IP, bitcoin, Austrian econ. You never know which one will lead to the others.

Query:

Subject: Layman questions on IP

… I’m writing you from [South American country] because I’ve recently become very interested in IP and after some research I came across some of your works as well as a few debates. I’ve been talking to people about this issue for some time now and I’m pretty surprised to see how deep rooted everyone’s defense of IP appears to be. Most recently I’ve been called a communist by my boss for expressing my opinion against there being IP at all. I’m reaching out to you because I’m working on a writing that introduces this topic for laypeople like me, and I wanted your take on a few things.

I should clarify I’m not formally trained in any type of law nor in economics. I’m just a guy who really enjoys reading and listening to Sowell and Friedman, and who, after doing enough of the Chicago gateway drug, got more and more into the Austrian stuff and what have you. I must say I’ve always been a skeptical person, if not cynical, but this has been an extremely sobering yet enjoyable experience. I knew some realities are sold to us upside down, but I didn’t know how many of them or how badly so.

The main question that motivates my reaching out is this:

If we know concentrated interest pretty much always prevails politically over diffused interest, and IP represents nothing but concentrated interests (hell, it even represents a mechanism to concentrate interest), what is the best strategy to advocate for an IP-less world? Is it by arousing or appealing to a dormant or potential concentrated interest that could emerge from change? Like a certain type of socially available but currently unexploitable talent.

People defend IP because of its “democratic promise”: everyone can get their own monopoly, yay! But even pointing out the absurdity of this might be too weak. Asking if, or even proving that that’s not how the greater social good (however that’s defined) is achieved doesn’t seem to be enough. In fact, I don’t believe “the greater good” sells at all. Not because people are evil, but because due to socialist education and other factors most can’t understand what it actually means nor can they already visualize it in the lives they live today. Gratitude is at a premium, and that certainly doesn’t help.

Also, I must add, we’re at a time in which it seems technology will exponentially elevate the costs of enforcing IP to the point the debate about it might even become obsolete. Do you think it more pertinent to gear the communication towards that than to making a case against IP as it still exists today?

Anyway, I apologize if you find this to be a bit all over the place, I just wanted to get your thoughts on how to best aim the divulging of this subject for laypeople like me, seeing that you seem to have taken up the responsibility to do so from your place as an IP lawyer with great success. I have a firm grasp of the ideas, the logic behind it, and even some intuitions of the equivalences between what’s being granted and what’s being taken away in order to do so. It’s very complex and ultimately requires empirical testing. So the presenting of the subject is covered. I’m just missing some empirical studies, which I’m currently researching in variety, and a good direction to point the core argumentation towards. Seeing that you’re a successful lawyer, I thought you’d know a thing or two about that.

Thank you very much for your time

Kinsella:

Yes, IP benefits mostly Hollywood, the music industry, and Big Pharma, mostly in the US, so because of US IP imperialism the whole world is paying for these three welfare recipients. But they don’t see it so they tolerate it because everyone has accepted the mistake that I think stemmed from Locke:
I fear the main problem is the deeply rooted creationism/labor theory of property mistake of Locke permeates everyone’s thinking so much that it is impossible to dislodge this by simple education or empirical studies. They would have to rethink their entire view of justice and property rights which is not possible without sustained thought. I think we are stuck with IP until it becomes unenforceable.

On the first and second points, see below. If you would like to discuss in a zoom call, I can give you 30 min. Just let me know.

Update (Nov. 12, 2026): (with assist by Claude) For a recent example of the “technology might” argument, see Dhruv Bansal, co-founder of Unchained, in “AI Will Change How The World Uses Bitcoin,” What Bitcoin Did (Oct. 13, 2026), and in his and Stephen Hall’s essay “Bitcoin Is All You Need,” Unchained. Bansal regards IP as a net negative and thinks artists would do better with patronage and direct support from fans. But his main point is about enforcement: IP can be defended only because distribution runs through centralized chokepoints like ISPs and platforms. He wants to rebuild the internet as peer-to-peer markets, paid in bitcoin, for packet routing, data storage, and computation. If someone, somewhere, will always route your packets or sell you a file for bitcoin over onion-routed channels, there is no one to send a takedown notice to. As the essay puts it, if peer-to-peer markets for data transmission and storage scale, “they will not just replace Amazon’s S3 and Google’s Cloud Storage – they will obsolete intellectual property,” since “[s]omeone somewhere will always be willing to sell you that file at the lowest possible cost the market can feasibly support.” AI speeds this up. The flood of AI traffic may break today’s ad-supported “free” internet and force a pay-per-packet one. And autonomous AI agents, paying for their own compute in bitcoin, may end up building and running these markets. As he says in the interview:

If the distribution mechanisms that we use to broadcast intellectual property become decentralized and peer-to-peer and pay-to-play, intellectual property itself dies. … It’s only when distribution becomes centralized that intellectual property becomes defensible. And if distribution becomes decentralized once more, then intellectual property will no longer be defensible, ergo will not have value, and people will stop trying to own it. … I don’t think that intellectual property is a net good in society. I think it’s a net negative.

I’m less optimistic about the timeline. As I’ve noted, in the near term copyright is more likely to hobble AI than the reverse. But Bansal has the mechanism right: IP will die when it becomes unenforceable, not when people are persuaded it is unjust. I am not sure if he has a coherent and principled case against IP or if he even wants it abolished, but he has some good points.

Related

Lockean Creationism

Circumventing IP

Hollywood, Music, Big Pharma and US IP Imperialism

Libertarianism, Anarchy, IP, Austrian Economics, Bitcoin: One Leads to the Other

Share
{ 1 comment… add one }
  • Paul Spooner November 9, 2026, 8:17 pm

    I think this charge of being a “communist” for opposing intellectual property is exactly backward in the sense that matters, and irrelevant in the only sense that it is true.

    IP and communism are opposite in direction, but the same in error. Both are a denial that Heaven and Earth are two realms. Earth is the realm of scarce things: bread, land, hammers. If I eat the loaf, you cannot. Heaven is the realm of ideas which may be given and kept at once. If you hear me sing, we both have the song.

    The communist sees the limitless abundance of Heaven and tries to demand it of Earth. The IP advocate sees the scarcity proper to Earth and tries to force it onto Heaven. One denies that bread runs out; the other denies that a song does not. Both end in coercion, because reality will not cooperate with either error, and the proud prefer exacting the toll of their own mistakes from others rather than admitting to the error themselves.

    That is why a man who says a song may not be shared as though it were bread is not the communist’s opposite; he is his reflection. I have tried to set this out here: [ip.tryop.com](http://ip.tryop.com/#IP-is-Inverse-Marxism)

    You have made the case against IP longer and better than I have. I only wanted to offer this rare piece of the puzzle, which I have not seen fitted elsewhere: that communism is the same mistake facing the other way. Locke’s labor theory, which you name as the root of the trouble, looks to me like one of the ways people smuggle Heaven into Earth’s accounting. They treat the making of a song as if it were the mixing of labor with a field.

    Your larger point, that creation is a source of wealth and not of property rights, sits on the same divide. The song enriches the world the moment it is sung; but only the bread can be owned, because only the bread can be lost.

Leave a Comment